Dreamcatchers For Abused Children
October , 2016

Dreamcatchers For Abused Children Store

How Long Has This Been Going On?

Posted by Sandra On April - 1 - 2010

Reported Abuse
Douthat cites data from the John Jay report (from where the above graph originates) to argue that “the moral/cultural/theological climate of the 1960s and 1970s encouraged a spike in sexual abuse.” He continues:

This data informs the conservative Catholic argument that the post-Vatican II exodus of straight men from religious life and the spread of a sexually-active gay subculture within the priesthood is the abuse scandal’s “elephant in the sacristy.” Liberal Catholics might counter that the priesthood has always been disproportionately homosexual, and that the sexual revolution probably just encouraged psychologically healthy gay priests to give up on the church entirely, leaving behind a clerical population tilted toward repression, self-loathing and the dysfunctions of the closet.  Whichever narrative you prefer, though, it’s hard to deny that something changed in the 1960s, and not for the better.

Ross responds to readers’ criticisms here. His obvious fallacy is conflating reported cases of abuse with actual cases of abuse.

Reporting sexual abuse by a priest before the 1970s would have been extremely, extremely unlikely. Who would have believed you? How would you bring such a taboo subject up? Given the authoritative structure of the church, the reverence with which priests were treated, and the shame and stigma attached to all things sexual, the chances that a raped child would report a priest’s abuse to the authorities or even his or her own family before the 1970s was minimal.

It makes much more sense to me that the rise in data is because of a cultural change that allowed more people to speak about abuse they had buried in their psyches for years and decades than that liberal social mores suddenly took over the groovy church and that’s what led the abuse to spike. Sure, when you look at a case like the notorious Paul Shanley, one might see a correlation. Some priests previously abusing in secret might have used some of the broader sexual revolution of the time as some kind of affirmation of their crimes. But it seems much more likely to me that the greater the cultural power held by the church, the greater the likelihood of successful exploitation of minors within it. Human nature has not changed. We have evidence of sexual abuse and misconduct in the priesthood for centuries, alongside deeply homosexual subcultures in monasteries and all-male “celibate” clerical elites. Would it not be surpriusing if this had not been going on, given fallen human nature and the structure of these institutions? I suspect the rate of abuse was much, much higher in the distant than in the recent past – but we never heard about it. And never will.



By the time you finish reading this, 15 children will have been abused; In the next five minutes, 30 more; Within the next hour, 360 more; And by tonight, close to 8,000+ children will have suffered from abuse, 5 of which will die. Child abuse has increased 134% since 1980 and is now considered a worldwide epidemic. The high jump in child abuse deaths and the shocking increase in statistics highlights the frightening lack of public knowledge.
Educate Yourself--Learn the Facts--It may Just Save a Child's Life!!

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.




    Effective 4/28/12
    (Click On The World To See LIVE Stats)

    free counters


    PO Box 142
    Peck, MI 48466
    Phone: (810) 275-0755

    All donations are 100% tax-deductible!

Recent Comments

OUR MISSION: To educate the public on child abuse signs & symptoms, statistics, intervention, reporting, prevention & assist victims & survivors in locating the proper resources necessary to enable & achieve a full recovery.

Recent Comments

Child Abuse Scandal Shakes BBC

On Nov-13-2012
Reported by Sandra

Monitor Your Child’s Facebook

On Feb-5-2013
Reported by Sandra

Martial Arts Instructor Arrested

On Jan-16-2011
Reported by Sandra
Copy Protected by Chetan's WP-Copyprotect.
%d bloggers like this: